Image Ordered

IG_64: Replica of a stucco and glass window with cypress trees, flowers in a vase, and inscription
(BE_Bern_BHM_IG_64)

Contact Details

Please specify your first name.
Please specify your name.
Please specify your e-mail address.
The e-mail address is invalid.

Please provide as much information as possible (publication title, database, publisher, edition, year of publication, etc.).

The Vitrocentre Romont can only provide you with its own photographs. We regret that we cannot supply images from third parties to you. If your order concerns photographs from third parties, we will send you the contact address from which the images can be obtained.

The personal data you provide in this form will be used by Vitrocentre Romont exclusively for the processing of your image order. Correspondence regarding the order will be archived for internal reference. The data will not be used for purposes other than those listed here, nor will it be passed on to third parties. By sending the order form, you agree to this use of your personal data.

Should you have any questions, please send us an e-mail: info@vitrosearch.ch.

Title

Replica of a stucco and glass window with cypress trees, flowers in a vase, and inscription

Type of Object
Artist / Producer
Studio
Dating
1908

Iconography

Description

This stained-glass window consists of four panels. In the rectangular middle panel (1) an Arabic inscription interspersed with red flowers in two cartouches one above the other is flanked by two cypress trees, framed on each side by a border with tendrils of red and blue four-petalled flowers. Below, an oblong panel shows a flower tendril (2). On both sides, three identical compositions with flowers in a blue vase flank the two central panels (3a–b). The flowers are arranged symmetrically along the central axis. Tulips, carnations, roses, and lilies are easily reconginizable. The vase is flanked by two flower stems and framed by a segmental arch. Contrary to Islamic stucco and glass windows of the same type, the flowers are depicted in a naturalistic way. A border of red, yellow-green, and blue circles frames the individual motifs of the three main panels. A whitish background with regularly arranged dots forms the background of all four panels.

Iconclass Code
25G3(CYPRESS) · trees: cypress
25G41(CARNATION) · flowers: carnation
25G41(LILY) · flowers: lily
25G41(ROSE) · flowers: rose
25G41(TULIP) · flowers: tulip
41A6711 · flowers in a vase
49L142 · Arabic script
49L8 · inscription
Iconclass Keywords
Inscription

bism-i l-lāh ar-raḥmān ar-raḥīm (the inscription evokes vaguely the phrase of the Basmala: In the Name of God, the Merciful, the Compassionate)

Technique / State

State of Conservation and Restorations

A few fissures. The dark-green and orange glass are corroded on the front side. The white lead has flaked off at several points.

Technique

Red, green, blue, yellow, dark yellow, and whitish glass, set in lead. Small circles are etched into the whitish glass. The brownish edges of the circles probably originate from the etching (they are not painted). The lead cames are painted on the front side with viscous white paint, most probably white lead.

Each panel is stabilized with two vertical iron rods and fixed on the rear by wooden batten.

Only in panel (2), with flower tendril: red- and blue-flashed glass, etched on the front side. The contours of the etched motifs are painted with a dark colour below and white lead at the top.

History

Research

The present window is a replica of a type of stucco and glass windows widespread in Egypt during the Ottoman period. It combines three standard motifs of qamariyyāt, which are Arabic inscriptions in yellow (gold) within a cartouche, cypress trees, and flowers in a vase. Whereas the first two motifs are simplified versions of their Islamic counterparts, the depiction of flowers in a vase remains close to its prototypes (see for instance IG_7, IG_166, IG_178, IG_255, IG_356), although there are obvious differences to Islamic examples, especially regarding the naturalistic depiction of the flowers here.

By the early 20th century, motifs such as the cypress tree or the flowers in a vase were already well known in the West, as richly illustrated books with depictions of such windows were circulating in Europe from the second half of the 19th century. Among the most important publications is Émile Prisse d’Avennes’ L’Art arabe d’apreÌs les monuments du Kaire (IG_30), published in 1877 and presented to a large public at the 1878 Exposition Universelle in Paris (Prisse d’Avennes [son], 1896, p. 53; Volait, 2013, pp. 107–108). Prisse d’Avennes included no fewer than four colour plates illustrating traditional qamariyyāt, among them the cypress tree (IG_42) and the flowers in a vase (IG_43) that may have inspired the French architect Henri Saladin (1851–1923), who designed the stained-glass window on behalf of Moser (see below).

Both motifs are widespread in Islamic decorative arts. They can also be found in numerous other media, such as ceramics, wood panelling, wall paintings, and textiles, over a long period of time, and in both sacred and profane contexts. Among the most sophisticated examples of stucco and glass windows with the flowers in a vase motif are those in the Sultan’s Lodge (hünkâr kasrı) of the Yeni Cami in Istanbul (1661–1663, date of the windows uncertain). According to Sarah Keller (Keller 2020, p. 35), the latter windows are of particular importance with regard to the replica discussed here, as Saladin included a description of the above-mentioned stucco and glass windows of the Yeni Cami in his 1907 Manuel d’art musulman (IG_45), where he wrote: ‘Ces vitraux sont très fins de dessin, d’une harmonie générale ton jaune avec des fleurs blues, blanches, rouges et quelques notes turquoise se détachant sur le réseau de plâtre percé d’une quantité de petits trous ronds vitrés de verre blanc qui forment à la vue un pointillé blanc et brillant excessivement fin.’ (‘These windows are of very refined design, with a harmonious general palette of yellows, while blue, white, and red flowers, and some notes of turquoise stand out from the plaster matrix, which is pierced by a number of small round holes glazed with clear glass; these present to the view a stippling of brilliant white points that is extremely fine.’) (Saladin, 1907, vol. 1, p. 533, note 1). The perforated stucco surface of the Ottoman windows, which caught Saladin’s attention, also played a central role in Moser’s replica. In order to enhance the authentic appearance of the window, executed in Western technique using lead cames instead of a stucco grille and a thin layer of plaster to structure the design and hold the pieces of glass in place, Saladin gave clear instructions to the Parisian glass-painter August Bruin (active 1872–1908), who executed the windows in the spring of 1908. Two letters, written by Saladin one year after the completion of the window, tell us more about the inventive technique applied by the Parisian glass-painter. Thus for the background Bruin used white opalescent glass from which holes have been etched out at regular intervals to replicate the characteristics of Islamic windows.

Apparently, Saladin was not entirely convinced by the effect achieved, as in May 1909 he proposed to Moser that an additional layer of céruse épaisse (lead white) (BHM, Saladin, 12 May 1909) be applied to the window, in order to achieve the desired effect, which was shown in a watercolour drawing (IG_65) enclosed in Saladin’s letter written the following day (BHM, Saladin 13 May 1909). However, it seems that this working-over was not executed as described, as during the examination of the window, no paint could be observed on the opalescent glass. Instead, all the lead cames were been covered with white lead to enhance the effect of traditional stucco grilles.

Like other 19th-century amateurs (see IG_426–IG_431, IG_48–IG_59, IG_91, IG_322IG_328, IG_484–IG_487), the eccentric Swiss collector and traveller to the East Henri Moser-Charlottenfels (1844–1923), who spent various years in Paris where he socialized with the city’s cultural elite, had a fumoir arabe installed in his home, Charlottenfels Castle in Neuhausen (Switzerland). This was done to present part of his growing collection of Islamic art (Giese, 2016; Giese, 2019a–c). Saladin, who took over the planning of the neo-Islamic interior in 1907, created an assemblage of original architectural pieces from Moser’s collection and contemporary replicas, among them the stained-glass window discussed here. The latter was sent to Neuhausen on 19 May 1908 (BHM, Bruin 19 May 1908), and Moser confirmed its delivery at Charlottenfels Castle in a letter to Bruin dated 3 June 1908 (BHM, Moser 3 June 1908).

Together with a wooden mashrabiyya of supposedly North African origin, Saladin’s replica contributed to the exotic atmosphere of the interior, which was donated to the Bernisches Historisches Museum together with Moser’s collection in 1914 and reinstalled in Bern as part of the museum's permanent exhibition (BHM, 109499). Located next to the newly built Moser Hall, a neo-Timurid exhibition room designed by Saladin (Kaufmann, 2019), where part of the Orientalische Sammlung Henri Moser-Charlottenfels was exhibited, the Fumoir is presented to the public in its new setting since 1922 (Zeller, 1915; Kläy, 1991).

Dating
1908
Period
1907 – 1909
Original Donor

Moser-Charlottenfels, Henri

Previous Location
Place of Manufacture
Owner

Bernisches Historisches Museum

Inventory Number
109499/6

Bibliography and Sources

Literature

Giese, F. (2016). From Style Room to Period Room: Henri Moser’s fumoir in Charlottenfels Castle. In: S. Costa, D. Poulot, & M. Volait (Eds.), Period rooms. Allestimenti storici tra arte, gusto e collezionismo: Atti del Convegno Internazionale, Bologna, 18-19 aprile 2016 (pp. 153-160). Bologna: Bolonia University Press.

Giese, F. (2019). International Fashion and Personal Taste: Neo-Islamic Style Rooms and Orientalizing Scenographies in Private Museums. In F. Giese, M. Volait, & A. Varela Braga (Eds.), À l’orientale: Collecting, Displaying and Appropriating Islamic Art and Architecture in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries. Arts and Archaeology of the Islamic World, 14 (pp. 92-110). Leiden/Boston: Brill.

Giese, F. (2019). Orientalisierende Fumoirs in der Schweiz: Islamische Architekturzitate zwischen Nachahmung, Abguss und Assemblage. In F. Giese, L. el-Wakil, & A. Varela Braga (Eds.), Der Orient in der Schweiz: Neo-islamische Architektur und Interieurs im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert. Welten des Islams, 10 (pp. 59–84). De Gruyter.

Giese, F., & Varela Braga, A. (2019). Translocating Metropolitan Display Strategies in 19th-century Europe: Frederick Stibbert, Henri Moser and their Orientalist Style Rooms. International Journal of Islamic Architecture, 8(1), 115-140. https://doi.org/10.1386/ijia.8.1.115_1

Handwritten letter by Auguste Bruin, Paris, 17 May 1908, Bernisches Historisches Museum, BHM Ethno. Inv. 1908.670.162.

Handwritten letter by Auguste Bruin, Paris, 19 May 1908, Bernisches Historisches Museum, BHM Ethno. Inv. 1908.670.162.

Handwritten letter by Henri Moser-Charlottenfels, Charlottenfels, 3 June 1908, Bernisches Historisches Museum, BHM Ethno. Inv. 1908.670.162.

Handwritten letter by Henri Saladin, Paris, 12 May 1909, Bernisches Historisches Museum, BHM Ethno. Inv. 1908.670.162.

Handwritten letter by Henri Saladin, Paris, 13 May 1909, Bernisches Historisches Museum, BHM Ethno. Inv. 1908.670.162.

Kaufmann, K. (2019). Samarkand in der Bundeshauptstadt – ein Ausstellungssaal im neo-timuridischen Stil für die Sammlung Henri Moser im Bernischen Historischen Museum. In F. Giese, L. el-Wakil, & A. Varela Braga (Eds.), Der Orient in der Schweiz: Neo-islamische Architektur und Interieurs im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert. Welten des Islams, 10 (pp. 142–162). De Gruyter.

Keller, S. (2019). "Glänzende Wirkungen" – neo-islamische Glasmalerei in der Schweiz. In F. Giese, L. el-Wakil, & A. Varela Braga (Eds.), Der Orient in der Schweiz / L’Orient en Suisse: Neo-islamische Architektur und Interieurs im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert. Welten des Islams, 10 (pp. 201–221). De Gruyter.

Keller, S. (2020). “De véritables merveilles d’exécution”: Les vitraux du fumoir arabe d’Henri Moser. In Giese, F., Volait, M. & Varela Braga, A. (Eds.). À l’orientale: Collecting, Displaying and Appropriating Islamic Art and Architecture in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries (pp. 28–38). Leiden/Boston: Brill.

Kläy, E. J. (1991). Orientalische Sammlung Henri Moser Charlottenfels. Bern: Bernisches Historisches Museum.

Prisse d’Avennes (son), É. (1896). Notice biographique sur Émile Prisse d’Avennes: voyageur français, archéologue, égyptologue et publiciste, né à Avesnes (Nord) le 27 janvier 1807, décédé à Paris le 10 janvier 1879. Paris: Société d’éditions scientifiques.

Saladin, H. & Migeon, G. (1907). Manuel d’art musulman (Vols 1–2). Paris: A. Picard. Retrieved June 26, 2024, from: ark:/13960/t2f76hh6w

Volait, M. (ed.) (2013). Émile Prisse d’Avennes (1807–1879). Un artiste-antiquaire en Égypte au XIXᵉ siècle. Le Caire: IFAO.

Zeller, R. (1915). Die orientalische Sammlung Henri Moser auf Charlottenfels. Jahresbericht des Historischen Museums in Bern 1914 (77–120). Bern: K. J. Wyss.

Image Information

Name of Image
BE_Bern_BHM_IG_64
Credits
© Bernisches Historisches Museum, Bern. Foto Christine Moor
Date
2017
Owner

Bernisches Historisches Museum

Inventory

Reference Number
IG_64
Author and Date of Entry
Francine Giese 2024; Sarah Keller 2024

Linked Objects and Images

Linked Objects
Drawing of the stained-glass window in the fumoir arabe of Henri Moser-Charlottenfels